Yikes – Where to begin? Well ladies – women in the limelight (especially you Meryl Streep) should be careful just what you’re posting online nowadays! “I’d rather be a rebel than a slave” is kind of the same as saying, I’m proud of my “weakness” because I’m glad I don’t have yours.
The quote was said supposedly by Emilie Pankhurst (a famous suffragette) during an impassioned speech at a London rally in 1913 – but I think historical context plays an important role here. Pankhurst meant she didn’t want to be bound by the rules of inequality (where men have more rights than women) but in today’s, arguably, “fairer” world – readers are drawn to understand the word “slave” to denote an imprisoned black male/female, whom stereotypically works for a wealthy white family. (We’ve all seen 12 Years a Slave, right?)
However – although the grammar is off key – there are multiple issues with this promotion shoot for the women’s new film “Suffragette”:
- All four women (left to right), Carey Mulligan, Meryl Streep, Romola Garai, and Anne-Marie Duff are white and therefore there is no fairly-equal racial context to the T-shirts
- Henceforth, the shirts are likening sexism to racism – making them one of the same thing, almost equals or inextricably linked
- The women aren’t part of a 1913 Women’s Rights rally but rather are taking place in a highly produced fashion shoot promoting their new movie
- In turn, they are taking away the importance of equality (both gender and race focused) and are using the shirts to promote a film for corporation purposes
We don’t have an inspiring set of women here – what we have is four wealthy white women perpetuating the idea that racism and sexism are one of the same thing, promoting a film with references to slavery. This isn’t OK and as many twitter users are pointing out – “Meryl should have known better!”
The film has already been slammed for not highlighting the fact that Black women were not given rights too in the UK and US and this T-shirt promotion isn’t helping the film’s wicked backlash from critics. Of course, the efforts of the movement on the whole should be celebrated. And yes, the quote was said 100 years ago, in a very different time and context. But that doesn’t negate the fact that to put it on a t-shirt today is to reinforce its underlying message which one Twitter user, Miz Jenkins, so eloquently spelled out: